Questions for Lau and Chang (1987)

  1. In what three ways is the winter monsoon not a 'mirror image' of the summer monsoon?
  2. a) the convective cell is over a maritime area instead of a continent; b) the diurnal cycle is strongly affected by land-sea breezes; c) the main heat source is over the equatorial divergence belt

  3. What does "baroclinic" mean in this context? How is it distinguished from "barotropic"?
  4. The density (mostly caused by temperature) of a baroclinic air mass is not a function of pressure alone. I.e., density can change even if pressure remains the same. In a barotropic airmass changes in density are caused by changes in pressure (often associated with changes in altitude).

  5. What is "Walker circulation"? "Hadley circulation?"
  6. Walker circulation is a zonally-oriented cell in the tropics that moves air upward in convection cells, east (or west) toward a jet stream minimum, where the air sinks to the surface and returns to the convection cell via surface winds driven by pressure gradients. Hadley circulation is a meridionally-oriented cell that begins in the tropical convection cell like the Walker circulation, but moves poleward with a low pressure cell pulling it to the left and the Coriolis force pulling it to the right (opposite in Southern Hemisphere), until it sinks beneath the subpolar jetstream and is returned to the low latitudes along the surface down a pressure gradient.

  7. If normal circulation includes strong convection over the "maritime continent", then speculate what might be the relationship between El Niño and the winter monsoon.
  8. El Niño is associated with weak convection over the maritime continent because the pressure at Darwin (northern Australia) becomes higher relative to the pressure at Tahiti (the Southern Oscillation). Since the cold surges of the winter monsoon seem to enhance convection in the tropics, if there are fewer cold surges, perhaps convection is weakened, increasing pressure in the Indonesia area and perhaps contributing to the onset of an El Niño.

  9. Why is it sometimes useful to analyze anomaly patterns?

Sometimes you are looking for a significant departure from a normal or average set of conditions. Anomalies are measures, positive and negative, from what is considered to be the long-term normative state. Geographical distributions of positive and negative anomalies can help the investigator discover the possible perturbing forces that drive a phenomenon. Something like El Niño does not involve the introduction of entirely new forces, but rather shifting of the position and relative strength of existing ones.