D.M. Anderson and W.L. Prell, "A 300 kyr record of upwelling off Oman during the late Quaternary: evidence of the Asian southwest monsoon" Paleoceanography, 8:193-208 (1993)

Monsoon upwelling

  • land-sea pressure gradient extends from surface high near 30°S to surface low over Asia
  • upwelling caused by combined influence of wind-driven coastal upwelling and open-ocean Ekman pumping

Previous studies

  • changes in rel. abundance of bulloides indicate that upwelling was reduced during the LGM and stronger at the precessional max at 9 kyr (insolation 8% greater than modern)
  • long time series so far contradict the assumption that precession drives upwelling variations; dominant cyclicity is 50 kyr at off-shore sites

Objectives of this study

  • Leg 117 sites (723 etc) are on the Oman margin, closer to shore than earlier sites
  • examined relative abundance of different species and changes in accumulation rates of foraminifer shells

STRATIGRAPHY

  • 800 m water depth; site 723 is at 18°N, 58°E
  • examined upper 60 m of core in holes A and B; mag susceptibility to correlate
  • ages assigned based on SPECMAP; used 17 tie-points; mostly to planktonic, but some to benthic record, when planktonic record lacked structure

RESULTS

  • bulloides abundance ranged from <10% to >60% in last 300 kyr; measured relative to 33 other species
  • average abundance in coretop samples is 36%
  • more abundant than coretops in interglacials and less in glacials
  • trend toward increasing abundance from 300 ka to present
  • 20-30 kyr cycles are superimposed on the 100 kyr glacial cycles
  • bulloides cycles are in phase with ice-volume changes

Foraminifer shell accumulation

  • number of whole shells in >150 µm fraction varies from <300 shells/gram to >5000 shells/gram
  • concentrations are greatest during interglacials and lowest during glacials
  • reduction can not be attributed to dilution by clay b/c sed rate is only 3-4x higher in glacial compared to interglacial
  • shell accumulation variation is more regular than bulloides abundance
  • 20 kyr cycles are larger during interglacial and smaller during glacial
  • shell concentration max may precede bulloides abundance max at some transitions, but is usually coincident
  • converted to shell accumulation rates; need sed rates and estimates of sed density
  • shell accumulation rates were higher during interglacials even though sedimentation rates were several times lower
  • dissolution appears to increase when shell accumulation rates are low (glacials) and vice versa

Spectral analysis

  • variance density (sigma-squared/frequency)
  • autocovariance function: correlations between observations as a function of the intervening time interval
  • largest concentration of variance in bulloides abundance and shell accumulation is at 100 kyr
  • second largest is at 23 kyr
  • cross-spectral analysis to examine timing of effects relative to causes
  • bulloides abundance/shell accumulation are in phase with insolation forcing at 100 kyr and with min ice volume
  • bulloides abundance/shell accumulation lags radiative forcing by 4 to 6 kyr at 23 kyr cycle
  • same result when cross-spectral analysis between upwelling proxies and the isotopic curve
  • shells/gram index may lead the min ice volume by ~1 kyr
  • is upwelling responding directly to summer insolation variations in precessional frequency or is it indirect, driven by glacial-interglacial changes at this frequency

bulloides abundance vs. shell accumulation as proxy of upwelling

  • below 36% the two measures are proportional; above 36% percent abundance increases more slowly than shell/gram
  • this transition is outside the range of modern values in Arabian Sea (3-36%)

DISCUSSION

  • dominance of the 100 kyr cycle indicates that the land-sea pressure gradient is sensitive to glacial-interglacial cycles
  • glacial-interglacial effects either inhibit SW monsoon response to precessional cycles in summer insolation or directly change tropical circulation in some other way that alters the land-sea pressure gradient

Comparison to off-shore sites

  • bulloides abundance is more constant off-shore, so variance is less
  • the dominant frequences are 1/50 kyr and smaller one at 1/23 kyr
  • these lag the inshore cycles by 2 kyr
  • difference is caused by positive wind-stress curl driven upwelling offshore
  • jet-like structure of the SW monsoon; NW of the axis of the jet, wind-stress curl is positive (upwelling), while SE of the axis it is negative (downwelling)
  • coastal upwelling is roughly an order of magnitude larger than wind-stress curl-driven upwelling
  • variations in offshore upwelling largely driven by changes in the location of the low-level jet
  • 1979-1982: strongest winds produce weaker offshore upwelling because wind stress curl is reduced; jet migrates to the NW when SW monsoon winds are stronger

Response of monsoon winds to changes in summer insolation

  • lower surface pressure over Asia are caused by increased summer insolation; result in increase in the land-sea gradient and stronger SW monsoon winds across Arabian Sea (model result)

Response of monsoon winds to changes in glacial boundary conditions

  • decrease in monsoon intensity during glacials caused by:
  • warmer Indian Ocean SSTs, expanded NH ice volume, lowered SL and higher land albedo; all increase pressure over Asia and decrease pressure over the ocean
  • monsoon more sensitive to albedo changes than SST (model result)
  • snow cover increases albedo and melting of snow back absorbs heat and adds moisture to soil; both decrease land-sea temperature contrast